Borders and Frontiers of Ptolemaic and Roman Egypt. The Case of Lower Nubia

Autor: Audrey Eller | Strony: 61–84 | DOI: 10.12775/EtudTrav.38.003

Streszczenie

Drawing on Egyptian and Meroitic sources, as well as archaeological evidence from the region, this paper offers an overview and a nuanced synthesis of how the frontier was shaped in Lower Nubia during the Ptolemaic and Roman periods, spanning nearly six centuries. The interactions between Egypt, the kingdom of Meroe, and various groups of Nubian people are examined to assess the porosity of this frontier zone. Trade and religion played key roles in the development of Lower Nubia and in the formation of a distinct regional identity. By investigating this region over a long chronological span and in its full historical complexity, the paper supports recent scholarship that has called for moving beyond modern, overly rigid interpretations of ancient frontiers and for challenging asymmetrical models that portray influence as flowing exclusively from Egypt and the Roman Empire toward the kingdom of Meroe.

Bibliografia

Adams, W.Y. 1977: Nubia. Corridor to Africa, London

Adams, W.Y. 1982: Qasr Ibrim: An Archaeological Conspectus, [in:] Plumley, J.M. (Ed.), Nubian Studies: Proceedings of the Symposium for Nubian Studies, Selwyn College, Cambridge, 1978, Warminster, 25–33

Adams, W.Y. 1983: Primis and the ‘Aethiopian’ Frontier, JARCE 20, 93–104

Adams, W.Y. 1985: Ptolemaic and Roman Occupation at Qasr Ibrim, [in:] Geus, F., Thill, F. (Eds), Mélanges offerts à Jean Vercoutter, Recherche sur les Civilisations, Paris, 9–17

Adams, W.Y. 2004: Site 6-G-9 and the Problem of Early Kushite Settlement in Lower Nubia, SudNub 8, 64–69

Alexander, J. 1988: The Saharan Divide in the Nile Valley: The Evidence from Qasr Ibrim, AAR 6, 73–90

Anderson, R.D., Parsons, P.J., Nisbet, R.G.M. 1979: Elegiacs by Gallus from Qaṣr Ibrîm, JRS 69, 125–155

Anonymous 1962: Missione Archeologica della Soprintendenza alle Antichità – Egittologia di Torino in Nubia, Aegyptus 42/1–2, 149–152

Ashby, S. 2020: Calling out to Isis: The Enduring Nubian Presence at Philae, Gorgias Studies in the Ancient Near East 13, Piscataway

Baldi, M. 2015: Isis in Kush, a Nubian Soul for an Egyptian Goddess, Journal of Intercultural and Interdisciplinary Archaeology 2, 97–121

Bishop-Wright, H.C. 2019: Reconsidering the Lower Nubian ‘Wine-Presses’ and their Leonine Spouts, SudNub 23, 158–168

Bishop-Wright, H.C. 2022: Dying for a Drink on the Meroitic Frontier: Imported Objects in Funerary Assemblages at Faras, Sudanese Nubia, Mare Nostrum. Estudos Sobre o Mediterrâneo Antigo 13/1, 87–121

Bishop-Wright, H.C. 2023: Chronology, Correspondence Analysis, and Lower Nubia in the 3rd Century BC: A Reassessment of the Meroitic Cemetery at Faras, SudNub 27, 230–246

Blackman, A.M. 1911: The temple of Dendûr, Les temples immergés de la Nubie, Cairo

Boozer, A.L. 2018: The Archaeology of Imperial Borderlands: A View from Roman Egypt and Sudan, [in:] Düring, B.S., Stek, T.D. (Eds), The Archaeology of Imperial Landscapes: A Comparative Study of Empires in the Ancient Near East and Mediterranean World, Cambridge, 206–239

Brambilla, C. 2015: Exploring the Critical Potential of the Borderscapes Concept, Geopolitics 20/1, 14–34

Breeze, D.J. 2011: The Frontiers of Imperial Rome, Barnsley

Breeze, D.J., Reddé, M. 2021: Frontiers of the Roman Empire. The Roman Frontier in Egypt/Frontières de l’Empire Romain, La Frontière Romaine en Egypte, Oxford

Burstein, S.M. 1993: The Hellenistic Fringe: The Case of Meroë, [in:] Green, P. (Ed.), Hellenistic History and Culture, Hellenistic Culture and Society 9, Berkeley, 38–66

Burstein, S.M. 2008: Elephants for Ptolemy II: Ptolemaic Policy in Nubia in the Third Century BC, [in:] McKechnie, P., Guillaume, P. (Eds), Ptolemy II Philadelphus and his World, Mnemosyme-Suppl. 300, Leiden, 135–148

Burstein, S.M. 2014: The Satrap Stela and the Struggle for Lower Nubia, [in:] Anderson, J.R., Welsby, D.A. (Eds), The Fourth Cataract and Beyond: Proceedings of the 12th International Conference for Nubian Studies, British Museum Publications on Egypt and Sudan 1, Leuven-Paris-Walpole, 573–576

Burstein, S.M. 2017: P. Michigan 281 and the Roman Occupation of Qasr Ibrim, [in:] Fantusati, E., Baldi, M. (Eds), Proceedings of the Fifth Day for Nubian Studies, Serie Orientale Roma 9, Roma, 61–68

Christophe, L.-A. 1963: Sanctuaires nubiens disparus, ChronEg 38, 17–29

Cooper, J.C. 2020: Toponymy on the Periphery: Placenames of the Eastern Desert, Red Sea, and South Sinai in Egyptian Documents from the Early Dynastic until the End of the New Kingdom, ProblÄg 39, Leiden-Boston

Cooper, J.C. 2022: Children of the Desert: The Indigenes of the Eastern Desert in the Pharaonic Period and the Longue Durée of Desert Nomadism, [in:] Cuvigny, H. (Ed.), Blemmyes. New Documents and New Perspectives. Including O.Blem. 1–107, DFIFAO 52, Cairo, 5–40

Cuvigny, H. 2019: Poste publique, renseignement militaire et citernes à sec : les lettres de Diourdanos à Archibios, curator Claudiani, Chiron 49, 271–297

Cuvigny, H. 2021: Rome in Egypt’s Eastern Desert, New York

Cuvigny, H. 2022: Trogodytes et Blemmyes, entre documents et littérature, [in:] Cuvigny, H. (Ed.), Blemmyes. New Documents and New Perspectives. Including O.Blem. 1–107, DFIFAO 52, Cairo, 41–59

Cuvigny, H., Bülow-Jacobsen, A., Faucher, T., Tereygeol, F. 2020: Agatharchide et les mines d’or du désert Oriental : Nouvelle traduction et commentaire des passages de Photius et Diodore, [in:] Redon, B., Faucher, T. (Eds), Samut Nord. L’exploitation de l’or du désert Oriental à l’époque ptolémaïque, FIFAO 83, Cairo, 319–324

Davies, W.V., Welsby, D.A. (Eds) 2020: Travelling the Korosko Road: Archaeological Exploration in Sudan’s Eastern Desert, SARS Publication 24, Oxford

Derda, T., Łajtar, A. 2012: Greek and Latin Papyri from the Egypt Exploration Society Excavations at Qasr Ibrim: A Testimony to the Roman Army in Upper Egypt and Lower Nubia in the First Years of Augustus, [in:] Schubert, P. (Ed.), Actes du 26e Congrès international de papyrologie, Genève, 16–21 août 2010, Geneva, 183–186

Derda, T., Łajtar, A. 2013: The Roman Occupation of Qasr Ibrim as Reflected in the Greek Papyri from the Site, [in:] van der Vliet, J., Hagen, J.L. (Eds), Qasr Ibrim, Between Egypt and Africa. Studies in Cultural Exchange (NINO Symposium, Leiden, 11–12 December 2009), EgUit 26, Leiden, 105–110

Derda, T., Łajtar, A., Płóciennik, T. 2019: ‘Receive (...) Four Pigs’: Pigs in the Papyri from Qasr Ibrim, Palamedes 13/1, 137–154

Desanges, J. 1969: Le statut et les limites de la Nubie romaine, ChronEg 44/87, 139–147

Edwards, D.N. 1996: The Archaeology of the Meroitic State: New Perspectives on its Social and Political Organisation, BAR-IS 640, Cambridge Monographs in African Archaeology 38, Oxford

Edwards, D., Rilly, C. 2007: Meroitic Stelae from Qasr Ibrim, [in:] Rose, P., The Meroitic Temple Complex at Qasr Ibrim, MEES 84, London, 76–92

Eide, T., Hägg, T., Pierce, R.H., Török, L. 1996: Fontes Historiae Nubiorum, Textual Sources for the History of the Middle Nile Region Between the Eighth Century BC and the Sixth Century AD, Vol. 2. From the Mid-Fifth to the First Century BC, Bergen

Eide, T., Hägg, T., Pierce, R.H., Török, L. 1998: Fontes Historiae Nubiorum, Textual Sources for the History of the Middle Nile Region Between the Eighth Century BC and the Sixth Century AD, Vol. 3. From the First to the Sixth Century AD, Bergen

Eller, A. 2022: Nomes et toparchies en Égypte gréco-romaine : réalités administratives et géographie religieuse d’Éléphantine à Memphis, BiEtud 179, Cairo

Fantusati, E. 2003: Roman Hiera Sykaminos, BSF 8, 41–47

Faraji, S. 2011: Kush and Rome on the Egyptian Southern Frontier: Where Barbarians Worshipped as Romans and Romans Worshipped as Barbarians, [in:] Mathisen, R.W., Shanzer, D. (Eds), Romans, Barbarians, and the Transformation of the Roman World: Cultural Interaction and the Creation of Identity in Late Antiquity, London-New York, 223–231

Firth, C.M. 1915: The Archaeological Survey of Nubia: Report for 1909–1910, Cairo

Fischer-Bovet, C., Sänger, P. 2019: Security and Border Policy: Army and Police, [in:] Vandorpe, K. (Ed.), A Companion to Greco-Roman and Late Antique Egypt, Chichester, 163–178

Francigny, V. 2016: Les coutumes funéraires dans le royaume de Méroé : Les enterrements privés, Orient & Méditerranée 22, Paris

Frend, W.H.C. 1980: Augustus’ Egyptian Frontier: Qasr Ibrim?, [in:] Hanson, W.S., Keppie, L.J.F. (Eds), Roman Frontier Studies 1979: Papers Presented to the 12th International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies, BAR-IS 71, Oxford, 927–930

Frend, W.H.C. 2004: Qasr Ibrim 1974: The Coins, JEA 90, 167–192

Griffith, F.L. 1929: Meroitic Studies VI, JEA 15, 69–74

Guédon, S. 2018: La frontière romaine de l’Africa sous le Haut-Empire, CCV 74, Madrid

Haensch, R. 2012: The Roman Army in Egypt, [in:] Riggs, C. (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Roman Egypt, Oxford, 68–82

Hallof, J. 2011: A Meroitic Offering Table from Maharraka – Found, Recorded, Lost or Not?, SudNub 15, 105–107

Hallof, J. 2020: The Meroitic Inscriptions from Qasr Ibrim, Vol. III. Inscriptions on Stone, Wood, Parchment and Gourd. Text, SRAT 9/5, Dettelbach

Haycock, B.G. 1972: Landmarks in Cushite History, JEA 58, 225–244

Heinen, H. 2000: Boéthos, fondateur de poleis en Égypte ptolémaïque (OGIS I 111 et un nouveau papyrus de la collection de Trèves), [in:] Mooren, L. (Ed.), Politics, Administration and Society in the Hellenistic and Roman World: Proceedings of the International Colloquium, Bertinoro 19–24 July 1997, StudHell 36, Leuven, 123–153

Hendrickx, B. 2014: On the Withdrawal of the Roman Troops from the Dodecaschoenos in AD 298: Many Questions and Few Answers – The Problems in Perspective, Akroterion 59/1, 47–65

Honzl, J. 2021: Religious Habits of the Roman Army in the Peripheries of Egypt. The Epigraphic Evidence, [in:] Coppens, F. (Ed.), Continuity, Discontinuity and Change: Perspectives from the New Kingdom to the Roman Era, Prague, 491–547

Horton, M. 1991: Africa in Egypt: New Evidence from Qasr Ibrim, [in:] Davies, W.V. (Ed.), Egypt and Africa: Nubia from Prehistory to Islam, London, 264–277

Hölbl, G. 2004: Altägypten im Römischen Reich: Der römische Pharao und seine Tempel, Vol. II. Die Tempel des römischen Nubien, Mainz a/Rhein

Kirwan, L.P. 1994: The Boethos Stela and Ptolemaic and Roman Qasr Ibrim, [in:] Bonnet, C. (Ed.), Études Nubiennes. Conférence de Genève : actes du VIIe congrès international d’études nubiennes 3–8 Sept. 1990, Geneva, 1–6

Kromer, K. 1967: Römische Weinstuben in Sayala (Unternubien), Berichte des österreichischen Nationalkomitees der UNESCO-Aktion für die Rettung der nubischen Altertümer, Vol. 4, DÖAWW Philosophisch-Historische Klasse 95, Vienna

Kuckertz, J. 2021: Meroe and Egypt, [in:] Willeke, W. (Ed.), UCLA Encyclopedia of Egyptology 1/1, https://escholarship.org/uc/item/6061m848 (accessed April 15, 2025)

Kuckertz, J., Moje, J. 2022: A Demotic Ostracon from Argin Mentioning Akinidad?, AntSud 33, 91–116

Laskowska-Kusztal, E. 2021: Comprehending Text – Appreciating Image: Text and Image Synergy in Research on the Remains of the Roman Temple of Osiris Nesmeti on Elephantine and the Ptolemaic Temple of Mandulis in Kalabsha, [in:] Beinlich, H. (Ed.), 12. Ägyptologische Tempeltagung: Synergie und Divergenz. Zum Zusammenwirken von Bild und Text in ägyptischen Tempeln, Würzburg, 2020, KSG 3/7, Wiesbaden, 149–174

Le Rider, G. 1969: Monnaies trouvées à Mirgissa, RevNum 11, 28–35

Leclant, J. 1977: Recherches sur la toponymie méroïtique, [in:] La toponymie antique : actes du colloque de Strasbourg, 12–14 juin 1975, TCRPOG 4, Leiden, 151–162

Leclant, J. 1982: Isis au pays de Koush, Annuaire EPHE: Ve section – sciences religieuses 90, 39–59

Locher, J. 1997: Die Schenkung des Zwölfmeilenlandes in der Ergameneskapelle von Dakke, ChronEg 72, 242–268

Locher, J. 1999: Topographie und Geschichte der Region am ersten Nilkatarakt in griechisch-römischer Zeit, AfP Beiheft 5, Stuttgart

Masson, O. 1976: Nouveaux graffites grecs d’Abydos et de Bouhen, ChronEg 51, 305–313

Maxfield, V.A. 2000: The Deployment of the Roman Auxilia in Upper Egypt and the Eastern Desert during the Principate, [in:] Alföldy, G., Dobson, B., Eck, W. (Eds), Kaiser, Heer und Gesellschaft in der Römischen Kaiserzeit, Gedenkschrift für Eric Birley, Heidelberger Althistorische Beiträge und Epigraphische Studien 31, Stuttgart, 407–442

Maxfield, V.A. 2009: Aswan and the River Nile: Frontier and Highway, [in:] Morillo Cerdan, A., Hanel, N., Manso Martin, E. (Eds), Limes XX. Estudios sobre la frontera romana / Roman frontier studies. XXth International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies, Leon (Espana), Septiembre 2006, Anejos de Gladius 13, Madrid, 73–84

Mueller, K. 2006: Settlements of the Ptolemies: City Foundations and New Settlement in the Hellenistic World, StudHell 43, Leuven-Paris-Dudley, MA

Muhs, B. 2013: Demotic Texts from Qasr Ibrim, [in:] van der Vliet, J., Hagen, J.L. (Eds), Qasr Ibrim, Between Egypt and Africa. Studies in Cultural Exchange (NINO Symposium, Leiden, 11–12 December 2009), EgUit 26, Leiden, 167–178

Nachtergael, G. 1997: Empreintes de pieds aux abords de Qasr Ibrim, ZPE 119, 188

Paprocki, M. 2019: Roads in the Deserts of Roman Egypt: Analysis, Atlas, Commentary, Oxford-Philadelphia

Parker, B.J. 2006: Toward an Understanding of Borderland Processes, AmAnt 71/1, 77–100

Préaux, C. 1951: Ostraca de Pselkis de la Bibliothèque Bodléenne, ChronEg 26, 121–155

Rilly, C. 2007: La langue du royaume de Méroé : un panorama de la plus ancienne culture écrite d’Afrique subsaharienne, BEHE Sciences historiques et philologiques 344, Paris

Rilly, C. 2022: Histoire du Soudan : des origines à la chute du sultanat Fung, [in:] Rilly, C., Francigny, V., Maillot, M., Cabon, O., Le Soudan : de la Préhistoire à la conquête de Méhémet Ali, EtudEg 23, Paris, 26–445

Rose, P. 1996: Qasr Ibrim: The Hinterland Survey, MEES 62, London

Rose, P. 2007: The Meroitic Temple Complex at Qasr Ibrim, MEES 84, London

Rose, P. 2009: Ptolemaic Qasr Ibrim: The Podium Revisited, [in:] Dodson, A., Ikram, S. (Eds), Beyond the Horizon: Studies in Egyptian Art, Archaeology and History in Honour of Barry J. Kemp, Vol. II, CASAE 36, Cairo, 423–438

Sethe, K. 1901: Dodekaschoinos: das Zwölfmeilenland an der Grenze von Aegypten und Nubien, UGAÄ 2/3, Leipzig

Sethe, K. 1904: Schoinos und Dodekaschoinos, ZÄS 41, 58–62

Siegel, O. 2025: An Appraisal of Pharaonic Egyptian Boundary Studies, EtudTrav 38, 11–34

Smith, S.T. 2014: Desert and River: Consumption and Colonial Entanglements in Roman and Late Antique Nubia, [in:] Dijkstra, J.H.F., Fischer, G. (Eds), Inside and Out. Interactions Between Rome and the Peoples on the Arabian and Egyptian Frontiers in Late Antiquity, Late Antique History and Religion 8, Leuven, 91–109

Speidel, M.P. 1988: Nubia’s Roman Garrison, [in:] Temporini, H. (Ed.), Politische Geschichte (Provinzen und Randvölker: Afrika und Ägypten), ANRW 2/10, Berlin-New York, 767–798

Stoll, O. 2008: Integration und doppelte Identität: Römisches Militär und die Kulte der Soldaten und Veteranen in Ägypten von Augustus bis Diokletian, [in:] Gundlach, R., Vogel, C. (Eds), Militärgeschichte des pharaonischen Ägypten: Altägypten und seine Nachbarkulturen im Spiegel der aktuellen Forschung, Krieg in der Geschichte 34, Paderborn, 419–458

Török, L. 1980: To the History of the Dodekaschoenos Between ca. 250 BC and 298 AD, ZÄS 107, 76–86

Török, L. 2009: Between Two Worlds: The Frontier Region Between Ancient Nubia and Egypt, 3700 BC – AD 500, ProblÄg 29, Leiden

Török, L. 2012: Between Egypt and Meroitic Nubia: The Southern Frontier Region, [in:] Riggs, C. (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Roman Egypt, Oxford, 749–762

Trigger, B.G. 1965: History and Settlement in Lower Nubia, Yale University Publications in Anthropology 69, New Haven

Troche, J.D. 2022: The Roman Egyptian-Nubian Frontier during the Reigns of Augustus and Amanirenas: Archaeological Evidence from Talmis, Qasr Ibrim, and Meroë, JAEI 36, 3–18

Van der Vliet, J. 2013: Qasr Ibrim in Lower Nubia: Cultural Interaction at the Southernmost Roman Limes, [in:] van der Vliet, J., Hagen, J.L. (Eds), Qasr Ibrim, Between Egypt and Africa. Studies in Cultural Exchange (NINO Symposium, Leiden, 11–12 December 2009), EgUit 26, Leiden, 1–22

Vercoutter, J. 1970: Mirgissa I, Mission Archéologique Française au Soudan 1, Paris

Weinstein, M.E., Turner, E.G. 1976: Greek and Latin Papyri from Qaṣr Ibrîm, JEA 62, 115–130

Wilkins, A., Barnard, H., Rose, P. 2006: Roman Artillery Balls from Qasr Ibrim, Egypt, SudNub 10, 64–78

Williams, B.B. 2002: The Descent of Meroe’s Power in Akiñ, [in:] Bács, T.A. (Ed.), A Tribute to Excellence: Studies Offered in Honor of Ernő Gaál, Ulrich Luft, László Török, StudAeg 17, Budapest, 493–506

Winter, E. 1981: Ergamenes II., seine Datierung und seine Bautätigkeit in Nubien, MDAIK 37, 509–513

Yellin, J.W. 1995a: Egyptian Religion and its Ongoing Impact on the Formation of the Napatan State. A Contribution to László Török’s Main Paper: The Emergence of the Kingdom of Kush and her Myth of the State in the First Millennium BC, CRIPEL 17, 243–263

Yellin, J.W. 1995b: Meroitic Funerary Religion, [in:] Haase, W. (Ed.), ANRW. Geschichte und Kultur Roms im Spiegel der aktuellen Forschung. Teil 2: Principat. Band 18: Religion. 5. Teilband: Heidentum (die religiösen Verhältnisse in den Provinzen [Forts.]), Berlin, 2869–2892

Zaki, G. 2009: Le premier nome de Haute-Égypte du IIIe siècle avant J.-C. au VIIe siècle après J.-C. d’après les sources hiéroglyphiques des temples ptolémaïques et romains, MRE 13, Turnhout

Žába, Z. 1979: The Rock Inscriptions of Lower Nubia (Czechoslovak Concession), Prague